Minutes – 11/10 – DRAFT

Attendance:

In Person

  • Amstadter, Logan
  • Anselmo, Paula
  • Bagwell, Geoffrey
  • Campbell, Holly
  • Conery, Todd
  • Carlson, Bobbi
  • Cosner, Rebecca
  • Cuisinier, Eddy
  • Deyo, Robert
  • Dubois, Rick
  • Edwards, David
  • Eggerman, Jason
  • Fadeley, Megan
  • Flock, Barb
  • Franklin, Jackie
  • Freed, Erin
  • Gates, Devika
  • Golden, MaryAnn
  • Guthrie-Martinez, Megan
  • Hardenbrook, Rebecca
  • Hein, Bradley
  • Kier, Laura
  • Kowtko, Stacy
  • Lopez-Schindler, Lenora
  • McCann, Samantha
  • Megow, Lyn
  • MitmaMomono, Christina
  • Morrow, Corrine
  • Pearson, Michelle
  • Rambo, Bill
  • Roe, Timothy
  • Satake, Katie
  • Satake, Scott
  • Shelton, Shawna
  • Stack, Brian
  • Sweeney, Joel
  • Throop, Judith
  • Trujillo, Cindy
  • Vanhoudt, Jenny
  • Vogel, Rob
  • Wanke, Colette
  • Woytalewicz, Christina

Online

  • Bem, Greg
  • Blek, Brad
  • Bishop, Adriana
  • Buckley, Michael
  • Cartwright, Ben
  • Case, Emma
  • Christman, Zachary
  • Commers, Ken
  • Cusack, Jessica
  • Daily, Bev
  • Dalsanders, Christie
  • Davis, Reid
  • Fox, Gigi
  • Gamble, Anna
  • Green, Sabina
  • Henry, Chad
  • Hawkins, Jen
  • Hoppe, Jessica
  • Kovarik, Camille
  • Kuhle, Teya
  • Martin, Melinda
  • McCoy, Jennifer
  • McLean, Scott
  • Moore, Michele
  • Moser, Heidi
  • Murphy, Helen
  • Pelham, Alex
  • Ping, Ping
  • Rasmussen, Angela
  • Reid, Davis
  • Whitmire, Kami
  • Wolfsen, Amy
  • Wright, Aryn
  • Wylie, Mark

Call to Order:  The meeting was called to order at 2:45 p.m. by Jason Eggerman.

Minutes and Finance

Approval of Minutes 

Bradley Hein motioned to approve the October minutes; Rob Vogel seconded. The motion passed.

Treasurer’s Report 

IncomeExpensesTotal Assets
End of Month
October$5,182.13$2,108.45$237,060.08

A member asked about the interest rate in the money market account and if we should consider moving funds from the money market into a more lucrative option. Geoffrey stated that he will add it to the next Executive Board agenda for discussion.

Bobbi Carlson  motioned to approve the October treasurer’s report; Bill Rambo seconded. The motion passed. 

Old Business 

Bargaining Commission

On October 27th, the Executive Board reviewed the list of volunteers for the Bargaining Commission. In three areas, including Allied Health on both campuses, faculty asked if they could volunteer with an alternate because of schedules and time commitments. The Executive Board agreed and felt this was a good way to ensure representation was more likely at each commission meeting.

The members selected were as follows: Jessica Cusack (SFCC, OTA), Megan Guthrie-Martinez (SFCC, PTA), Thomas Nelson (SFCC, IS/CS), Michelle Pearson (SFCC, Biology), Shawna Shelton (SFCC, Counseling), Devika Gates (SFCC, Chemistry), Lena Lopez-Schindler (SFCC, Art, adjunct member), Marty Sells (SCC, Nursing), Sam Tevis (SCC, Machinist/CNC), Jackie Franklin (SCC, Accounting), Geoffrey Bagwell (SCC, Philosophy), Holly Campbell (SCC, Biology), Tim Roe (SCC, English), Christina Woytalewicz (SCC, Accounting, adjunct member), Kammi Whitmire (SCC, Dental/EFDA), Kimmy Eikum (SCC, Radiology Tech), Emma Case (SCC, Medical Office Specialist), Sabina Green (SCC, Medical Office Specialist), Russell Schluter (SCC Extensions, rural member, Welding/Fabrication), Bobbi Carlson (SCC Extensions, Corrections), Logan Amstadter (SCC Extensions, ESL), and Rob Deyo (SCC Extensions, ABE).

Corrine Morrow motioned to approve the Bargaining Commission; Bradley Hein seconded. The motion passed.  

Jason thanked the members of the Bargaining Commission for being willing to do this important work and commented on how pleased he is to see such broad representation. The commission plans to meet once or twice each month between now and June. The general membership will periodically receive small surveys (similar to the ones last spring) as the commission begins gathering data on various topics. 

New Business

Faculty Job Announcements (Position Descriptions)

AHE is working with HR to ensure any information listed in the “Duties and Responsibilities” portion of job announcements is consistent with the Master Contract. General faculty duties and responsibilities are spelled out in Article 4, Section 4 of our Master Contract. There have been things included recently in job announcements that have raised concerns. For example, there were job announcements implying that faculty could be required to teach Flex classes or teach in the “Hyflex” modality. We do not currently have a “Hyflex” modality defined in our Master Contract. Additional concerns have centered around language saying that faculty would teach classes while, “utilizing appropriate pedagogy,” or “utilizing evidence based instructional practices.” While these sound good on paper, they are subjective. As such, they could be used later to imply faculty must teach in a certain style, which would infringe on academic freedom. There have also been things discussed previously during bargaining that have later appeared in job announcements. This is particularly concerning, since the agreement in bargaining was not to add some of those things to Article 4, Section 4. While there are elements of specific duties and responsibilities that vary from position to position, that section of job announcements still should align closely with Article 4, Section 4 of our Master Contract.

Jason also reminded the Senate that step placement for new hires is based on how they meet the preferred qualifications in the job announcement. Step placement is outlined in Article 19, Section 3. New full-time faculty are placed at Step 1 if they meet the minimum qualifications, Step 2 if they meet “a subset” of the preferred qualifications, and Step 3 if they “meet or exceed” the preferred qualifications. The same placement criteria are used for faculty in High Demand areas, but using Steps 4, 5, and 6 instead of Steps 1, 2, and 3. Faculty serving on future screening committees should understand that, while it may be tempting to list many preferred qualifications, having too many can make it impossible to place a new hire at Step 3 (or Step 6 for High Demand). Several departments were surprised last year when their new colleague was placed lower than new faculty in other departments. It was unfortunately due to how they wrote the job announcement in a way that it was not possible to “meet or exceed” the long list of preferred qualifications. 

Tim Roe gave examples of how screening committees in English at SCC have strategically approached this by writing flexible preferred qualifications using the word “or.” For example, rather than having one preferred qualification for having a PhD and another preferred qualification for having at least five years of teaching experience, the bullet point might instead be written as: “Either a PhD or five years of teaching experience.” This gives the new hire more of a chance at higher initial step placement.   

Jason reminded everyone that new full-time faculty have one year to appeal their initial step placement. If a new faculty member thinks they should have been placed higher on the salary schedule, they can appeal to the College President. We would encourage them to reach out to AHE for support in that process, and we encourage doing so sooner rather than later, because it can only be done for one year after their date of hire.

Required Safety Trainings (HSI)

The District and AHE have been working on a framework for offering and documenting appropriate safety training related to each faculty member’s worksite. This conversation has been in conjunction with Nicole Hannah’s office, Human Resources, and the VPI/VPL. The process starts with a walk-through of a faculty’s worksite by District safety staff, which is followed up by a survey and collaborative conversation with the faculty and dean to ensure that only appropriate trainings are being assigned. The trainings vary in length from 4 or 5 minutes up to about 30 or 40 minutes. Each training is online through “HSI”(Health and Safety Institute), and the trainings are assigned and tracked on that platform. Some trainings would be assigned only once upon initial hire, while others would be recurring annual trainings. The specific trainings assigned would depend on the work each faculty does and the risks involved.  The District will prioritize higher safety risks, so some faculty may not hear anything about this in their area for a while. 

AHE and the District have reached tentative agreement on several key issues and are finalizing an MOU that should go into effect in January. The key points of the agreement are:

  • Any HSI training assigned to adjuncts will be compensated. 
  • Compensation will be at the non-instructional rate listed in Article 24, Section 6, Paragraph C. 
  • Any training assigned to faculty teaching in programs that use workload Category F would be compensated at the non-instructional rate. 
  • Payments would be in the form of a stipend and would be processed at the end of each quarter, based on trainings completed that quarter. 
  • The listed times in HSI will be used to determine the length of each training, and all times will be rounded up to the nearest 15-minute increment (e.g. a training listed as 21 minutes will count as 30 minutes). 
  • Full-time faculty teaching in programs that do not use workload Category F can be asked to complete one (1) hour per quarter (excluding summer) of HSI safety training as part of their regular professional responsibilities. After that, training will be compensated at the non-instructional rate.
  • Training can be assigned in bulk, and faculty can be given multiple years to complete training. For example, a faculty member might be assigned five (5) hours of training on a two-year timeline. In that case, none would be compensated because it is less than one hour per quarter over the course of the two year time frame. However, if a faculty member were assigned 12 hours to complete over two years, then six hours would be above and beyond the one-hour-per-quarter threshold, so that six hours would be compensated.
  • The start and end dates of training certification cycles will ideally align with a full-time faculty member’s step movement cycle dates (July 1 to June 30).
  • Any training that is at least 16 minutes in length can be used under the Safety & Security practices category of the “A La Carte” category for step advancement. 
  • Two different trainings could count for both Safety and Security and “A La Carte” (i.e. one in each category). 

Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) and Cell Phones 

An email came out from IT on October 21 about a ctcLink change related to use of email for multi-factor authentication (MFA). The option to use email for MFA is no longer available. This was a state-wide change with ctcLink, not a local decision. AHE expressed concerns about the very short lead time of being notified on a Wednesday about a change to take effect the following Monday. District IT leadership has acknowledged that they did not provide enough advanced notice, and the CIO has committed to more advanced notice in the future as well as sharing updates with AHE at Joint Executive meetings. 

One option for MFA would be using either the Okta Verify or Google Authenticator application (which both require use of a smartphone). Faculty can also receive a SMS/Text message or voice call. The voice call can be done through a cell phone or through a desk phone or the “softphone” application on a work computer if faculty have that set up. There is also the option to use a YubiKey. Faculty interested in the YubiKey option should contact their dean. IT cannot order YubiKeys for faculty.  

AHE has voiced concerns over the past few years about the expectation that faculty use their personal cell phones at work. This has included the assumption that faculty can sign in using QR codes at trainings (instead of offering a sign-in sheet) and the assumption that everyone should use the Campus Shield application to contact Security from their smartphones instead of having office or classroom phones that could be used to call Security. AHE continues to remind the District that not all faculty own a cell phone and not everyone carries their phone around at work. This is a topic we plan to continue discussing. There is also a perceived double-standard that faculty are not allowed to use state resources for personal use, but the state has no problem asking faculty to use their personal equipment for work purposes. Jason mentioned that the new CIO would be reviewing “de minimus” use policies with the Business Office.

Members asked questions about whether the District can push back against this kind of decision at the state level due to the impact it has on students. Jason said he would ask and will bring up the point about how this impacts students at the next Board of Trustees meeting. 

Members pointed out that not all students have access to multiple devices. A member shared an example where a students’ inability to pay their cell phone bill led to their service being shut off. Losing the ability to authenticate meant the student could not access Canvas to do their classes..

Members reiterated their concern about the perceived double standard of the state not allowing personal use of state devices, but continuously asking state employees to use personal devices for work-related functions. Jason mentioned that he has made the CIO aware of this perceived double standard. 

Jason asked the Senate if they would like to have the CIO come and visit Senate to answer questions about IT issues. The Senate was in favor of the idea, so Jason will connect with the CIO about availability. One member suggested also inviting District Information Security Officer Nate Walker.

President’s and Vice Presidents’ Reports

AHE President Jason Eggerman:

The Chancellor sent notifications about decisions on the RIF process for the Pharmacy Tech and Hospitality, Tourism, and Event Management (HTEM) programs. In both cases, after meeting with the faculty in a one-on-one conference, the Chancellor decided to continue with the RIF of the programs. Both programs will be working with deans and the VPI at SCC to ensure a “teach out” of existing students. 

A member asked about retraining leave for faculty who are in the RIF process. Jason said this is still in the contract. Retraining leave is in the same article as professional leave (Article 7, Section 9) and takes priority over professional leave (i.e. it should be granted before sabbaticals). However, retraining leave is only for up to one year, so there has to be something available that the person could retrain into within one year.

Jason reported that he heard from several members by text message who expressed concern during the recent Chancellor’s Town Hall that a question about consultants that was in the online chat might have been ignored or skipped. After the Town Hall, Jason asked the Chancellor how questions in the chat are handled during town hall meetings. The Chancellor said his assumption was that all questions, excluding something that might be truly bizarre or wildly inappropriate, should be asked. The Chancellor stated he does not want anyone to feel their question in the online chat would ever be ignored or skipped simply because the question might be uncomfortable or tough. This would undermine trust and defeat the purpose of having an open forum. The Chancellor said he will follow up with his team to reaffirm this before the next Town Hall.

There will hopefully be a solicitation coming soon for a District Parking Task Force. Since this is a District task force involving both colleges, the solicitation email will come from Jason.

Transfer faculty will receive a survey about the AA-DTA. Later, there will be a solicitation for the AA-DTA Task Force. Jason said he expects that solicitation to come out some time before the Thanksgiving break. Jaclyn and Bonnie are working on the task force’s charge and said they hope to have selections made by the end of the quarter so that the group can start work in January. Since this is a District task force involving both colleges, the solicitation email will come from Jason. 

A member pointed out the survey should also be sent to Counselors at SCC, since they teach GUID 102 and that is part of the conversation. Another member pointed out the survey should be shared with transfer faculty in the Rural division at SCC, not just the two main campus transfer divisions. 

Chief Financial Officer Dr. Linda McDermott will be retiring in February. Faculty names were solicited and sent to the Chancellor in late October. The screening committee is being assembled and will be chaired by SCC President Dr. Jenni Martin. 

Human Resources has hired a new HR Director of Talent Management, Christina Vigil Gross. HR has said this is a cost-neutral move, combining the duties of two positions that had been vacant since this past summer. This brings the number of HR Directors up to three, as Christina joins HR Director of Information Systems (Melody Matthews) and HR Director of Employment Services (Tim Fackenthall). Melody Matthews is retiring in June. 

A member asked whether faculty can find out how much we are spending on administrators now compared to five years ago. Jason mentioned that this question had come up last year at BPAC (Budget Planning Advisory Committee) with regards to the increase in the number of administrative positions over the years. The member will reintroduce the question again this year at BPAC with more of a focus on the dollar amount being spent.

Jason mentioned that WEA is soliciting nominations for the 2026-27 WEA CTC Educator of the Year. The award recognizes the outstanding contributions CTC educators make to their colleges, communities, professions, and students’ lives. Any faculty member, including adjuncts, is eligible to be nominated. Jason sent out the link in an email prior to the Senate meeting. Nominations will be accepted until 5 p.m. Friday, Dec. 18. The application process requires a letter from a union leader, so reach out to Jason or one of the VPs if you need help. Your Senator or other Exec Board member could also help with this.

SCC VP Tim Roe:  

SCC will be working on utilizing more of the functionality of CTCLink. Since we were the first adopter we had to create workarounds to make things work for us, but a significant amount of functionality has been created over the past 10 years (making it much easier and more effective for colleges that came on board with CTCLink more recently). We will work on utilizing more features. This should not impact faculty other than work flows or processes may change (the change to the early alert process is a good example).

Faculty in the BHIT division should be receiving an invitation from Vice-President Jacot for a meeting with the BHIT division later this quarter to discuss the next steps in the decision making process.

We know there are issues with both noise and odors in Building 1. Please continue submitting work orders if there are issues. Also, if anybody needs to move their office or their classrooms let your dean know.

SCC Extension VP Rob Deyo:

Corrections has hired Shauna (Schmerer) Williams as the new Associate Dean of Corrections Education.  She will begin her new role on December 16th.  Thanks to Kellee Mote, Bobbi Carlson, Eric Kerkove, and Dan Burdick for serving on the screening committee.  

Rob recognized Extension faculty representation on the Bargaining Commission.  It’s important to have the perspective of folks from unique programs like ABE/ESL, Corrections and Rural when going into contract negotiations.   

SFCC VP Shawna Shelton:  

Toni Pizello has been hired into the annualized position in the Management department. He had previously been a finalist for the position so, when it was vacated, administration offered it to him. The Management department is happy to have Tony joining them in a full-time role.  

Shawna shared an update on the presidential search at SFCC. There were 38 applications, and the screening committee extended offers to 10 applicants for interviews. Of those, 8 have accepted an interview. The committee is in the process of scheduling those, and they are hoping for open forums for finalists during the second week of January.

There was an email from the VPL about position requests. Similar to last year, because of budget constraints, they won’t be following the initial timeline that had been sent out back in September. Decisions on replacements will happen later in the year. Unfortunately, the email shared, “It is likely that many positions will go unfilled this year.” 

Shared governance was discussed by faculty in a breakout session at the end of the recent all college meeting.  Currently, two of the three governance committees do not have a faculty tri-chair. Shawna also noted that DEGA has two of the three faculty positions vacant and said she will be soliciting for those vacancies again. Shawna gave a shout out to Alex Pelham (faculty tri-chair on Budget Governance). He offered to share info with anyone who might have questions about being a tri-chair. 

Adjunct Representative Lena Lopez Schindler:

An email should have gone out last week about adjunct training. Adjuncts should check that out and reach out if they have any questions about completing or checking their training. 

Good of the order:

Jackie Franklin made a motion to adjourn.  Scott Satake seconded. The meeting adjourned at 4:27pm